A Year With Rouhani, Moderate Minister of Murder

Just over a month ago, an article appeared in Canada’s Globe and Mail titled “The Iran You Won’t Hear About From Ottawa.” In it, seasoned journalist Jeffrey Simpson described a Canadian businessman’s journey to Iran, in which he racked up experiences “radically different from the black-and-white reporting in parts of the Western media.”

To his credit, Simpson noted that the businessman “obviously” didn’t encounter “the Revolutionary Guard or secret police, very nasty parts of the regime.” He then casually brushed off an “appalling” warning by Canadian Foreign Minister John Baird that Iran was the “biggest threat to global peace.”

Baird, apparently, is not one to stay silent. This month, on the one-year anniversary of Iranian President Hassan Rouhani’s election on a moderate ticket, he published a lengthy op-ed in Foreign Policy magazine, “The Iran You Won’t Hear About From President Rouhani,” which catalogued all the ways in which the Iranian president’s promises of change culminated in just the sort of dismal reality Simpson’s “Western media” so likes to “demonize.”

Where Rouhani had promised, in “profoundly seductive” tones, dignity for minorities and co-operation with the world, a slew of human rights abuses had transpired: defense lawyers imprisoned, political prisoners beaten bloody, members of minorities executed.

Or is it figures you want? Baird’s got those too: at least 470 executed since the president’s June 2013 inauguration, an achievement for which he has since been dubbed (unofficially, of course!) “Minister of Murder.”

And what his overtures to the West? The highly-publicized prisoner releases, the humanitarian reforms, the anti-extremism rhetoric? It’s all been just talk for a year now, says Baird. Most of the “promised” prisoners weren’t even released, the “reforms” entrenched existing inequalities, and the statements against extremism have been translated into a $3.6 billion line of credit for Bashar Assad.

Black-and-white? Possibly, but not in the way Simpson meant. Baird’s demand for “reform rather than rhetoric” seems more like a sensible rule of thumb for Western journalists and leaders to go by than a “bombastic generalization.” Who’s black-and-white now?

Blogging & updating on #Iran related news- focusing on Politics, Human Rights & the Iranian nuclear Program. Followed by top Middle East Analysts, Reportes & think tanks.

Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Posted in Hassan Rouhani, Human Rights, Iranian Internal Issues, Iranian Politics, IRGC, Media Coverage
9 comments on “A Year With Rouhani, Moderate Minister of Murder
  1. […] a “moderate” ticket, we have been hard-pressed to find evidence of Rouhani’s moderation: the unprecedented rise in executions certainly doesn’t fit the bill, nor does the continued belligerency towards the United […]

  2. […] an op-ed castigating Rouhani’s speech for “falling short on human rights,” which have worsened in Iran under his watch, while the wife of a US pastor held in Iran expressed skepticism towards Rouhani’s offer to swap […]

  3. […] made it clear he was voting for Rouhani” – a leader whose so-called “moderation” we have called into question on more than one […]

  4. […] crime? Grassroots activism against the death penalty, which Rouhani’s “moderate” regime has used liberally and continues to use, including against child […]

  5. […] wizened up to Iran’s “naïve” moderate vs. hardliner act, particularly after executions shot up alarmingly under the “moderate” Rouhani during his three years in office? Are the aims of the two factions […]

  6. […] to “frustrate” the “moderate” Rouhani. Thus, the Iranian president – under whom arrests, executions and corporeal punishments have surged, among other indications that there isn’t much substance […]

  7. […] While some media outlets are still holding onto the notion that the Rouhani administration is a “moderate” one, most have by now caught onto the fact that nothing could be further from the […]

  8. […] the regime’s actions – even under Rouhani – present an entirely different picture (we have already reported somewhat about this in July), […]

  9. […] human rights. In recent years – under the “moderate” President Hassan Rouhani – Iran has stepped up its use of the death penalty, including against underage offenders, LGBTQs, women, and more. But most […]

What's on your mind?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow us in any way you like!
  Like on FacebookFollow on Twitterstumble uponFlickrPinterest

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 38,317 other followers

Visuals to Share
Visitor Count
  • 1,384,753
Follow us on Twitter
%d bloggers like this: